Tears of the kingdom vulkan or opengl

Vulkan is better for most things, but some games work better with OpenGL. As kraut said, it's okay to switch to check to see if the other is better. That said, unless there's some issues, vulkan is generally considered to be the recommended default. try both, see which one works best for you on a game-per-game basis.

Tears of the kingdom vulkan or opengl. Yuzu Emulator The Legend Of Zelda Tears Of The Kingdom 4K | OpenGl vs Vulkan | RTX 4070Ti Benchmark Share Add a Comment. Be the first to comment Nobody's responded …

Crying is natural and healthy, but sometimes, it can be inconvenient. We look at various short-term and long-term ways to stop crying. First thing’s first: It’s normal to cry. But ...

In the realm of computer graphics, the evolution of Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl has been a captivating journey, leading to the creation of stunningly realistic and immersive visual experiences. Two prominent contenders in this realm are Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl, both of which have played vital roles in …I figured it out, to anyone wondering the shaders were not loading because I wasn’t on EA build of yuzu. They are not transferable. Steam Deck cache works with the Steam Deck only. Shader Cache are GPU and driver versions dependant. I recommend build your own shaders. When I transfer any precompiled shader files into TOTK it completely resets ...Read the latest update report of yuzu, the Nintendo Switch emulator, and learn about the new features, fixes, and improvements that have been made in January 2023.Yeah, the default in yuzu is vulkan. There are a few games that run better in OpenGL on certain setups, and it's fine to use it there, or when there's issues with vulkan. 7. Reply. krautnelson. • 1 yr. ago. yes, Vulkan is the better option in most situations. Vulkan is the successor to OpenGL. it has better performance, more room for ...Ryzen 5 4600h. Despite being from 2014, the 4790 (especially K version) has nearly identical single core performance as a 4600H (from 2020). I have run ToTK on 4 P cores on an 13500H 13th gen laptop (locked using process lasso) and it is fine and hitting up to 90 fps. Admittedly, the single-core performance is much higher than both of those CPUs.Tears of the Kingdom not working with vulkan. The game works fine with a relatively high frame rate in the intro. After the ganondorf cutscene the whole emulator crashes. Is I open it again the emulator crashes once I load the save file. Opengl works fine visually but with 5 fps due to me using an AMD gpu.

Try both, use whichever is faster. Reply. GoldenX86. •. OpenGL on GLSL offers the highest framerate, usually. Also the slowest shader build speed. Vulkan offers the fastest shader building, and good performance. Start with Vulkan first and use OpenGL if needed. Reply.Nintendo games have the tendency to get leaked days, if not weeks, ahead from the proper release date, and as usual, The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom is no exception, more so given the anticipation of the sequel to the highly acclaimed Breath of the Wild, released 6 years ago. The game...Now im using Yuzu Early Access 3611 with standard settings Vulkan, firmware 16.0.3 and keys (WITHOUT ANY MODS - but installed the Update 1.1.1.) and an undervolted i5-9300H CPU (-147,5 voltage for CPU and -147,5 voltage cache and -55,7 iGPU = i did all these with the TrotthleStop 9.5 Program = about 80° degree mobile CPU now - So its pretty ...Now im using Yuzu Early Access 3611 with standard settings Vulkan, firmware 16.0.3 and keys (WITHOUT ANY MODS - but installed the Update 1.1.1.) and an undervolted i5-9300H CPU (-147,5 voltage for CPU and -147,5 voltage cache and -55,7 iGPU = i did all these with the TrotthleStop 9.5 Program = about 80° degree mobile CPU now - So its pretty ...Just for some clarification, this bug didn't show up until I made it to hyrule kingdom. I have tried using opengl but that drops the performance way way down. the game runs completely smooth and only has this one visual bug that completely breaks immersion. Any tips would be welcomed. I am running on a gtx 2060 using vulkan and the 30fps mod.IMPORTANT that you don't make these common mistakes when visiting the United Kingdom. Knowing these should make your trip less stressful. Increased Offer! Hilton No Annual Fee 70K ...Try the build with Vulkan instead.. OpenGL runs like a turd with an AMD GPU on Windows, I couldn't get past that point either. Scroll down until you see the different links, then click the lowest option for win_x64. Runs almost perfectly for me, only a stutter here and there.A The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom (TOTK) Mod in the Visual Overhaul category, submitted by throwawaytodownloadmods Visual Fixes [The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom] [Mods] Ads keep us online.

The Nvidia OpenGL driver is best in class and the Vulkan one is top notch too. The only Vulkan driver that could be considered better is RADV. Eh, people with GCN3 and earlier still want to play emulators and performance with OpenGL is still bad on Windows. Their problems go away with Linux, but that's not the point.performance is roughly the same today I'd say, only difference is that the RAM and VRAM requirements have drastically improved. overall RAM usage went from well above 16GB to roughly 12GB, and VRAM is at around 3-3.5GB with uncompressed textures. What an answer, thanks a lot man. Hi everyone, even tho i wanted to play it more than everything ...Vulkan : r/Ryujinx. Switch Emulation on Deck -- OpenGL VS. Vulkan. Vulkan continues to be a game changer. Stoked they put the work in to get it going well with Ryujinx. I'd love to see some comprehensive comparisons between Vulkan Ryujinx vs yuzu on deck. I do it myself I had the time. 36K subscribers in the Ryujinx community. Ryujinx is a ...This video is about the best settings in tears of the kingdom Yuzu to get 4k60FPS stable gameplay on newer hardware and most old hardware should be able to g...It'll cause less stutter and make the experience smoother but won't lead to higher fps. But I recommend using a shader cache for a smoother experience. Your mileage may vary though. 3. Reply. Nicnl. • 10 mo. ago. Compiling shaders on the fly causes FPS drops. Using an existing shader cache would lead to less FPS drops.

How many mcgs are in a milligram.

I'll do a video this week, where I'll test Yuzu (vulkan) vs Ryujinx (vulkan) and soon I'll be posting it here. Goated. Thank you. yes would also love this, im right on the hardware cusp where i can run some games in one or the other some times and love that there are two options but am frequently confused how to choose.Set OpenGL PixelPackBuffer to 0 when done. Fixes emulator screenshots being taken as black pictures when using OpenGL. Fixes camera photos and save previews being taken as black pictures in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom when using OpenGL. May fix similar issues in other games when using ...I prefer without wifi just in case)Use DDU to unistall both drivers (The way I did it was Nvidia first, restart back into safe mode, then removed AMD).Go back into normal windows, install one of the drivers (AMD first for me)Restart, and repeat for the other driver. After I did this, my computer was able to handle Vulkan for Ryujinx again, and ...As far as vendor-specific bugs go, Tears of the Kingdom came with plenty of baggage. For Nvidia users, the Vulkan backend was performing much worse than it should have, and in some scenarios up to 57% slower than OpenGL. The gap only widened when scaling to higher resolutions.

Hello Everyone,welcome to my new video,This tutorial is about Low FPS problem and Best Performance Settings for the Legend of Zelda Tears of the Kingdom …Quote:" Vulkan performance and compatibility have improved significantly (especially if paired with the Texture Reaper, the GPU Cache Garbage Collector), additionally, rendering and shader build performance almost always beat OpenGL. This applies not only for AMD and Intel GPU users, but also Nvidia users." Shader Cache for TOTK Vulkan yuzu. I don't know if this is more comfortable for you to play later, this is the shader cache that I have but I know that I still have things to unlock, at least the most everyday things are already loaded like 20000 shaders. The build also reduces menu stuttering in Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom as well as performance improvements by around 10% on AMD GCN 4/polaris cards. This build can also improve Red Dead Redemption ...Table of Contents hide. Simple Ways to Play Zelda Tears of the Kingdom on PC. Method 1: Try using a cloud service. Method 2: Use an emulator. Playing Zelda Tears of the Kingdom using Yuzu emulator. Play Zelda Tears of the Kingdom on PC with Ryujinx. Play the game using the CeMu emulator.May 15, 2023 · E como será que tá o desempenho do zelda: Tears of the Kingdom em PC fraco? eu fiz o teste no i5 9300H e uma GTX 1650 e o desempenho...👉Vire membro do canal... A diferencia de Breath of the Wild, Tears of the Kingdom no es un mundo abierto, sino tres mapas en capas. Una de las novedades de Tears of the Kingdom son las Islas del Cielo, situadas en lo alto de Hyrule y que ofrecen una vista impresionante del paisaje. Las nuevas habilidades de Link son una de las mayores evoluciones de Breath of the Wild.Aug 15, 2023 · In the realm of computer graphics, the evolution of Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl has been a captivating journey, leading to the creation of stunningly realistic and immersive visual experiences. Two prominent contenders in this realm are Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl, both of which have played vital roles in shaping […] Yuzu ea 3705 Game version 1.1.2 Vulkan Accuracy level high Force maximal clocks on Enable reactive flushing on Use fast time gpu hack on Use vulkan pipeline cache on Sync to frametime of video playback on Barrier feedback loops on Anisotropic filtering 16x. Mods Anisotropic filtering fix Camera jpeg quality increase Disable internal fxaa exefs ...May 9, 2023 · Update Comparison Yuzu vs Ryujinx: https://youtu.be/9cLJqu4ha34The mods are compatible only with version 1.1.0.FSR Fix (Yuzu): https://ouo.io/cIodT7Yuzu Fix...

Utilizing Vulkan, in the case of most emulators, allows for far better performance, and that extends to Ryujinx as well. This major change will make compiling shaders noticeably faster than with OpenGL, though when the latest release featuring Vulkan does release, it will cause your current built shader cache to stop existing.

Try both, use whichever is faster. Reply. GoldenX86. •. OpenGL on GLSL offers the highest framerate, usually. Also the slowest shader build speed. Vulkan offers the fastest shader building, and good performance. Start with Vulkan first and use OpenGL if needed. Reply. A The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom (TOTK) Mod in the Visual Overhaul category, submitted by throwawaytodownloadmods Visual Fixes [The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom] [Mods] Ads keep us online.The game runs fine on OpenGL but I've been told it runs much better with Vulkan so I was hoping there was some sort of solution. My graphics drivers are up to date. Tears of the Kingdom does not even load, Ryujinx just instantly crashes whenever I …It's a dirty build for Ryujinx that I found: Use Vulkan with this build. OGL still crashes, but Vulkan doesn't. Set the resolution to native with Vulkan, you take a big frame rate hit for higher resolutions unlike with OGL. But if you want to eliminate the crashes, this is the only working fix. I was previously crashing every 10-20 minutes with ...Performance comparison. Vulkan does amazing actually, the results show that Vulkan more than triples the FPS compared to OpenGL ES 3.1. There are a few reasons to why this is. First, it may be ...Vulkan is better for most things, but some games work better with OpenGL. As kraut said, it's okay to switch to check to see if the other is better. That said, unless there's some issues, vulkan is generally considered to be the recommended default. try both, see which one works best for you on a game-per-game basis.E como será que tá o desempenho do zelda: Tears of the Kingdom em PC fraco? eu fiz o teste no i5 9300H e uma GTX 1650 e o desempenho...👉Vire membro do canal...Try Yuzu EA PineappleEA 3559 Download the hacked .exe replacement for the yuzu .exe file Try Vulkan Try the YuzuFix 3.2a patch Try the FSR/blur patch Update the game 1.1.0 And finally, make sure your shader cache from 1.0.0 is deleted from your yuzu shader folder if you had tried it with 1.0.0 already Also the latest Ryujinx should have fixed ...

Weather monroe township nj.

Aldi careers usa.

Just for some clarification, this bug didn't show up until I made it to hyrule kingdom. I have tried using opengl but that drops the performance way way down. the game runs completely smooth and only has this one visual bug that completely breaks immersion. Any tips would be welcomed. I am running on a gtx 2060 using vulkan and the 30fps mod.Comparison between Yuzu and Ryujinx for TOTK on my 5800x + RTX 3080 rig. It's pretty telling.Have the same issue on a i5-1035G1 (ICL GT1) on Linux (Fedora). Crashes at "Tears of the Kingdom" both in OpenGL and Vulkan. BOTW works just fine, so I don't think is a requisites problem. Can't upload a log since the app straight up hangs and I gotta kill it, so I don't think it includes anything relevant to the crash, just boot info and so.May 29, 2023 · I'm using default settings on Ryujinx. The game runs fine on OpenGL but I've been told it runs much better with Vulkan so I was hoping there was some sort of solution. My graphics drivers are up to date. Tears of the Kingdom does not even load, Ryujinx just instantly crashes whenever I double click the game. Reproduction steps Read the latest tech news in United Kingdom on TechCrunchApr 22, 2024 · Cheat Codes Add and Request group The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom cheat codes Pokémon Legends: Arceus cheat codes Xenoblade Chronicles 3 cheat codes Fire Emblem Engage cheat codes Request a cheat... Quote:" Vulkan performance and compatibility have improved significantly (especially if paired with the Texture Reaper, the GPU Cache Garbage Collector), additionally, rendering and shader build performance almost always beat OpenGL. This applies not only for AMD and Intel GPU users, but also Nvidia users." Vulkan API: Preferred over OpenGL for Tears of the Kingdom, offering better stability and performance. How to achieve stable 60 FPS in The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom on PC Achieve 60FPS without mods : Possible in version 3615 , indicating significant optimizations in recent Yuzu versions.First, launch the Yuzu Emulator, click on the Emulation option, and then select Configure. Leave the General tab on default, and do the same with the CPU option. Now, the next tab, Graphics, is pretty important. When it comes to your GPU, if you have an AMD card, select Vulkan as the API. Nvidia users should opt for OpenGL. ….

Jun 6, 2023 · There are two API settings available in Yuzu; OpenGL and Vulkan. While most games perform exceptionally well with Vulkan selected in the API settings and your dedicated graphics card set as the Device, some perform better with OpenGL. Hence, switch the API to see if it improves performance. To do that, follow the below steps: None is faster than the other. It's just that the CPU should have a higher usage with OpenGL. So if you are CPU limited, Vulkan should be faster. You can also do more things with Vulkan, than with OpenGL. The others explained it well but Vulkan is a lower level API with reduced CPU time on the driver.How to Mend Rips and Tears - Instead of throwing out clothes that are damaged, learn how to mend rips and tears yourself. Learn about practical mending techniques. Advertisement Of...In fact, OpenGL 4.6 came out recently, long after Vulkan went 1.0. On Linux, the open-source OpenGL drivers are excellent, you just need to use the latest Linux kernel if you have a Vega. There are two open-source Vulkan drivers for AMD as well, but there's still a large amount of room for optimization in those. 1.That's a shame the stutters are breaking the game, we'll wait x. Poor cpu is chugging hard with the emulation. Shader comp seems to be an issue with this game too. 34K subscribers in the Ryujinx community. Ryujinx is a Nintendo Switch Emulator programmed in C#, unlike most emulators that are created with C++ or….May 9, 2023 · Update Comparison Yuzu vs Ryujinx: https://youtu.be/9cLJqu4ha34The mods are compatible only with version 1.1.0.FSR Fix (Yuzu): https://ouo.io/cIodT7Yuzu Fix... I maybe figured that out. vulkan.bin is shareable/transferable. vulkan_pipelines.bin is not. Flush your shader cache, unpack someone else's vulkan.bin to the specific directory. Open the game in Yuzu, then it will build your own vulkan_pipelines.bin at launching. based on your gig and graphic card driver.Vulkan is a much more modern and "lower-level" API than OpenGL, and as such, gives developers much more granular control over the GPU hardware; a blessing and a curse in all regards. While this level of detail can be beneficial when trying to accurately emulate a system, it can also provide for hours of misery having to do quite literally ... Tears of the kingdom vulkan or opengl, vulkan.bin is indeed shareable. Yuzu then will build your own vulkan_pipelines.bin based on your gig and graphic card driver. Reply reply PM_ME_SOLES_OR_TOES • I feel like I've heard things about a 70k cache on the old subreddit. ... If anyone is interested here is my Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan.bin. 46,600 shaders compiled on yuzu., I haven't used this emulator in a while but in Yuzu's " Project Hades " a lot of things changed in the graphic department so as of now, which api backend is the best choice for me in the latest version of Yuzu, OpenGL or Vulkan ? This is my system specs: [CPU]: Intel Core i7-4790K 4.0GHz. [GPU]: EVGA GeForce GTX 970 Superclocked ACX 2.0 4GB GDDR5. , Vulkan is a much more modern and "lower-level" API than OpenGL, and as such, gives developers much more granular control over the GPU hardware; a blessing and a curse in all regards. While this level of detail can be beneficial when trying to accurately emulate a system, it can also provide for hours of misery having to do quite literally ..., Last Breath. 2.09K subscribers. 649. 35K views 10 months ago. ...more. This video is about the best settings in tears of the kingdom Yuzu to get 4k60FPS stable …, In fact, OpenGL 4.6 came out recently, long after Vulkan went 1.0. On Linux, the open-source OpenGL drivers are excellent, you just need to use the latest Linux kernel if you have a Vega. There are two open-source Vulkan drivers for AMD as well, but there's still a large amount of room for optimization in those. 1., Ryujinx 1.1.1011. 1x resolution(720p/1080p) using a Ryzen 7 5800X and RX 6600 8GB. Enjoy!Vulkan backend. Docked. Bilinear.Please Like and Subscribe!Want to s..., However, OpenGL is a higher-level API compared to Vulkan, which means it requires more API calls to draw a frame. This can result in less efficient performance, especially on modern hardware with powerful graphics processors. Conclusion. In summary, Vulkan, DirectX, and OpenGL are three widely used graphics APIs that are used for …, May 29, 2023 · I'm using default settings on Ryujinx. The game runs fine on OpenGL but I've been told it runs much better with Vulkan so I was hoping there was some sort of solution. My graphics drivers are up to date. Tears of the Kingdom does not even load, Ryujinx just instantly crashes whenever I double click the game. Reproduction steps , Set OpenGL PixelPackBuffer to 0 when done. Fixes emulator screenshots being taken as black pictures when using OpenGL. Fixes camera photos and save previews being taken as black pictures in The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom when using OpenGL. May fix similar issues in other games when using ..., Default settings and Vulkan if your GPU supports it. Ryujinx works out of the box and is already on the best settings by default. You can of course tinker with the graphics settings (resolution, antialiasing, scaling filter, anisotropic filtering) so you can achieve the proper image quality for your setup, but you shouldn’t change anything else unless specified in …, Vulkan is better overall, due to better performance and very little shader stuttering (if using async shader compilation). But if your system IS fast enough with openGL, and you download a complete transferable cache for the game, you can COMPLETELY eliminate stuttering, so openGL is still preferable in that situation. 1., Ryujinx 1.1.1011. 1x resolution(720p/1080p) using a Ryzen 7 5800X and RX 6600 8GB. Enjoy!Vulkan backend. Docked. Bilinear.Please Like and Subscribe!Want to s..., driver 531.68 is working. Your Nvidia driver seems to be too old. Update your Nvidia driver, that fix black texture. I had the exact same issue and updating drivers got it to work on Vulkan. OpenGL also did the trick but was less smooth for me., Choose Vulkan when GPU cycles directly impact user experience, like AAA games or VR rendering where the API’s efficiency and predictability shine. Otherwise OpenGL still offers a battle-hardened foundation for real-time graphics. Augmenting rather than abruptly discarding this versatile toolkit is pragmatic for many., Vulkan and Direct3D 12 are really low level and require a lot of work that may not pay out for small projects. Direct3D 11 and OpenGL >3.1 (core profile) are nice to work with if you are a bit experienced in how GPUs work in general and you need modern features like geometry, tessellation or compute shader stuff., Vulkan API: Preferred over OpenGL for Tears of the Kingdom, offering better stability and performance. How to achieve stable 60 FPS in The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom on PC Achieve 60FPS without mods : Possible in version 3615 , indicating significant optimizations in recent Yuzu versions., I'll do a video this week, where I'll test Yuzu (vulkan) vs Ryujinx (vulkan) and soon I'll be posting it here. Goated. Thank you. yes would also love this, im right on the hardware cusp where i can run some games in one or the other some times and love that there are two options but am frequently confused how to choose., Try Yuzu EA PineappleEA 3559 Download the hacked .exe replacement for the yuzu .exe file Try Vulkan Try the YuzuFix 3.2a patch Try the FSR/blur patch Update the game 1.1.0 And finally, make sure your shader cache from 1.0.0 is deleted from your yuzu shader folder if you had tried it with 1.0.0 already Also the latest Ryujinx should have fixed ..., Now im using Yuzu Early Access 3611 with standard settings Vulkan, firmware 16.0.3 and keys (WITHOUT ANY MODS - but installed the Update 1.1.1.) and an undervolted i5-9300H CPU (-147,5 voltage for CPU and -147,5 voltage cache and -55,7 iGPU = i did all these with the TrotthleStop 9.5 Program = about 80° degree mobile CPU now - So its pretty ..., I haven't used this emulator in a while but in Yuzu's "Project Hades" a lot of things changed in the graphic department so as of now, which api backend is the best choice for me in the latest version of Yuzu, OpenGL or Vulkan?This is my system specs: [CPU]: Intel Core i7-4790K 4.0GHz [GPU]: EVGA GeForce GTX 970 Superclocked ACX 2.0 4GB GDDR5 …, In this video we will have a comparison that was requested a lot on the Reddit forum and here in the youtube comments. Which API runs your games best? OpenGL..., I haven't used this emulator in a while but in Yuzu's " Project Hades " a lot of things changed in the graphic department so as of now, which api backend is the best choice for me in the latest version of Yuzu, OpenGL or Vulkan ? This is my system specs: [CPU]: Intel Core i7-4790K 4.0GHz. [GPU]: EVGA GeForce GTX 970 Superclocked ACX 2.0 4GB GDDR5. , Google Tears of the Kingdom Ryujinx or something along those lines and you'll get results that take you to roughly the right place. Anyone who knows about this stuff is either pirating or frequenting forums/discord chats about piracy, Resetera has rules against that so people probably aren't willing to link you to what you need directly., Open GL emulation is more precise even at framerates higher than 30fps. It is also less prone to have some weird glitches on textures and geometry. Untill Cemu 1.16 there was no vulkan, so the majority of tweaking was made on opengl, not that it means it's better. It takes forever to compile the first time., Cheat Codes Add and Request group The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom cheat codes Pokémon Legends: Arceus cheat codes Xenoblade Chronicles 3 cheat codes Fire Emblem Engage cheat codes Request a cheat..., It can help you unlock in-game secrets in Breath of the Wild while you wait for Tears of the Kingdom to release in May. In anticipation of the new The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the..., Yeah, the default in yuzu is vulkan. There are a few games that run better in OpenGL on certain setups, and it's fine to use it there, or when there's issues with vulkan. 7. Reply. krautnelson. • 1 yr. ago. yes, Vulkan is the better option in most situations. Vulkan is the successor to OpenGL. it has better performance, more room for ..., BENCHVERSE. 36 subscribers. Subscribed. 13. 3K views 7 months ago. Hello everyone! here's a quick benchmark of TOTK on Ryujinx 1.1.792. In this benchmark, I've compared the performance difference..., Shader Cache for TOTK Vulkan yuzu. I don't know if this is more comfortable for you to play later, this is the shader cache that I have but I know that I still have things to unlock, at …, Ryujinx 1.1.1011. 1x resolution(720p/1080p) using a Ryzen 7 5800X and RX 6600 8GB. Enjoy!Vulkan backend. Docked. Bilinear.Please Like and Subscribe!Want to s..., Alternatively, Vulkan is to OpenGL as DirectX 12 is to DirectX 11. The key element we want to discuss is what it means to be 'low-level' and how that changes the game engine. This gets technical ..., Open GL emulation is more precise even at framerates higher than 30fps. It is also less prone to have some weird glitches on textures and geometry. Untill Cemu 1.16 there was no vulkan, so the majority of tweaking was made on opengl, not that it means it's better. It takes forever to compile the first time., In the realm of computer graphics, the evolution of Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl has been a captivating journey, leading to the creation of stunningly realistic and immersive visual experiences. Two prominent contenders in this realm are Tears of the Kingdom Vulkan or Opengl, both of which have played vital roles in shaping […]